Tipster Proofing

Racing-Index proof the back and lay bet selections of various tipster services. To better illustrate the profits that could have been achieved, following the tipsters, we show performance figures based on Betfair SPs (BSP).

For back to win selections we provide a performance comparison of BSP versus regular SP. For lay bets we just show figures based on BSPs, which will give you a more accurate guide to tipsters past performance.

When following the selections of a tipster you should be looking towards long term profits. We therefore focus on services that have been proofing selections for at least 12 months and have returned a profit during that period. So that you can also monitor services that have shown good potential, over a shorter period, we also show performances over 6, 3 and 1 month.

Take time to look at the tables below and click on either the full list to see how other tipsters have performed or click on an individual tipster link to view a breakdown of their results.

Comparison Tables

Below are comparison tables for the past 12 months, 6 months, 3 months and 1 month performance. To see a complete list of services that proof their selections click on the "Full List" link. When viewing the full list you'll have the option to sort via Profit, POT% or VBP.

12 Months Backing
5th December 2022 to 4th December 2023
ServiceBetsSR%SP ProfitBSP ProfitVBP
Precision Betting46956.9-13.8-0.9502
Racing Nation Noteworthy49825.7-25.520.6335
The UK HRE - Chase Specialist59726.6-53.55.2307
SP2A - Place Spotter59023.6-81.91.425
Place Profits21771.45.55.5-100
Horsenberg36814.1-28.78.0-187
SpeedRatings.com Best Bets32414.8-46.3-8.1-224
Intelligent Betting36141.0-33.0-20.1-293
EBR - Diamonds and Gold16829.8-41.3-32.2-386
Racing Nation15221.1-14.7-6.3-429
Full List >>
6 Months Backing
5th June 2023 to 4th December 2023
ServiceBetsSR%SP ProfitBSP ProfitVBP
SP2A - Northern and AW expert30925.2-9.539.1567
Festival Tips10025.051.864.1452
Advance Ratings - System 125730.7-19.83.8450
SP2A - Daily Tips65525.6-117.3-23.7396
Racing Nation Noteworthy15924.54.426.2175
Paul Young13822.58.918.9168
SP2A - Place Spotter18522.7-5.933.5152
Horsenberg25814.7-34.6-4.9102
Intelligent Betting4839.61.63.620
Racing Nation6119.77.712.6-15
Full List >>
3 Months Backing
5th September 2023 to 4th December 2023
ServiceBetsSR%SP ProfitBSP ProfitVBP
Advance Ratings - System 112335.0-0.311.1630
SP2A - Mentions26928.6-11.431.8555
SP2A - Northern and AW expert12326.00.620.0243
Intelligent Betting2552.09.110.1201
Festival Tips3324.2-1.8-0.4158
SP2A - Tracker Accumulator90223.6-145.7-23.798
SP2A - Place Spotter8924.7-10.4-5.880
Horsenberg13514.8-25.0-13.669
Racing Nation Noteworthy7021.411.726.366
Racing Nation3818.413.416.0-12
Full List >>
1 Month Backing
5th November 2023 to 4th December 2023
ServiceBetsSR%SP ProfitBSP ProfitVBP
Football Racing Genius5644.626.235.1636
SP2A - Michael Gould Showcase6827.9-11.4-4.0315
Advance Ratings - System 17233.3-12.2-8.8245
Stable Winners10822.2-5.52.6243
Racing Nation1435.79.911.4225
The UK HRE - High Flyers Racing13920.1-1.129.3212
The UK HRE - Gold Turf Racing8822.7-12.63.1201
Intelligent Betting1060.08.38.9185
Festival Tips2123.80.82.2171
Investment Betting3363.6-1.1-0.4104
Full List >>
12 Months Laying
5th December 2022 to 4th December 2023
ServiceBetsSR%BSP ProfitVBP
Profit Punter Racing - Lay Club24577.11.282
Stable Lays127665.8-6.5-463
Worldwide Tipping Services84680.3-17.2-473
Precision Tipsters - Silver71485.7-8.6-683
Precision Tipsters - Bronze111172.0-57.1-3499
Horse Exchange Betting Tips10.0-1.0-19
Precision Betting10.0-1.0-64
Racing Nation2466.7-4.6-270
Full List >>
6 Months Laying
5th June 2023 to 4th December 2023
ServiceBetsSR%BSP ProfitVBP
Stable Lays63267.416.1538
Horse Racing Advisor3060.01.760
Profit Punter Racing - Lay Club19176.40.216
Worldwide Tipping Services61083.8-17.2-491
Precision Tipsters - Silver34385.4-6.5-502
Precision Tipsters - Bronze59671.6-31.5-1882
Precision Betting10.0-1.0-64
Racing Nation1866.7-3.2-191
Full List >>
3 Months Laying
5th September 2023 to 4th December 2023
ServiceBetsSR%BSP ProfitVBP
Profit Punter Racing - Lay Club8477.40.3-7
Precision Tipsters - Silver14887.2-0.1-14
Worldwide Tipping Services30484.9-8.9-20
Stable Lays24066.3-2.2-137
Precision Tipsters - Bronze29573.9-6.9-497
Horse Racing Advisor771.41.681
Precision Betting10.0-1.0-64
Racing Nation850.0-3.1-198
Full List >>
1 Month Laying
5th November 2023 to 4th December 2023
ServiceBetsSR%BSP ProfitVBP
Precision Tipsters - Silver4791.52.2150
Precision Tipsters - Bronze9176.92.092
Profit Punter Racing - Lay Club2080.00.858
Stable Lays7568.01.438
Worldwide Tipping Services12584.8-4.6-10
Full List >>
Key:

SR% = Success Rate % (e.g. an each-way bet that returns a profit is classed as a success even if the horse doesn't win the race).
SP Profit = Total profit backing all selections to 1 point level stakes at SP, during the period shown.
BSP Profit = Total profit backing all selections to 1 point level stakes at Betfair SP, taking into account commission of 5%.
VBP = Variable Bet Profits based on Betfair SPs.